Bonaire at $363 RT

Holy cow, Houston! You guys have only ever seen one single deal to the ABC islands. It was to Aruba, it was part of a bundle, and it was two years ago.

So when we say these fares are overdue, you know we mean it.

This time, you'll be landing in Bonaire—Aruba's cooler, more laidback, and low-key prettier cousin. There are fewer resorts and shopping districts here, but what it lacks in boutiques, it makes up for with the best diving spots on the planet. Seriously, as gorgeous as the beaches are, you won't want to set foot on dry land until you get hungry (or thirsty).

No worries if you pass on this one, though. At this rate, you'll be getting a Curaçao deal in early 2028 :-)