The Caribbean & Central America 
in $210s-$340s RT
OliviaJFC
This is quite the treasure trove! We're not sure what possessed American to suddenly empty a cargo ship's worth of tropical trips onto Atlanta, but we know better than to question a good thing.
There are really no bad options here – pretty much every destination on this list comes with perfect sandy beaches, rainforest hikes, tasty fried seafood, or all of the above. Highlights include that rare route to Antigua (a regular contender for "prettiest Caribbean island"), the first decent Belize fare we've seen since early 2024, and a smattering of summer break and Christmas holiday trips.
So pull up a chair and prepare to dig in 
Jack's take
Wow! We've scarcely seen any decent Caribbean fares since the fuel spike, but American just dropped a boatload of them onto Atlanta – with a side of mainland Central America to boot. The longer we searched, the more we found. It's been years since some of these routes were anywhere near these prices.
We've capped our list here to only include fares under $350 RT, but if you'd like to see what's available just beyond that mark, you can use this map.